How newcase.ai Is Unlocking Litigation Intelligence for Insurance Defense
Turning Private Case Data Into Strategic Advantage
Rafael Sainz

Empowering Defense Attorneys to Work Smarter, Not Slower
Attorneys defending insurers are buried in unstructured data, depositions, filings, and expert testimonies, making research slow, repetitive, and prone to missed insights. newcase.ai solves this by turning scattered historical records into a structured, AI-powered knowledge base that automates review, accelerates research up to 15x, and instantly surfaces contradictions, risk factors, and patterns in prior cases.
newcase.ai is the first AI platform built specifically for insurance litigation. Designed for defense teams, it transforms unstructured and proprietary case data into litigation intelligence, from profiling opposing counsel and expert witnesses to surfacing contradictions, pre-existing conditions, and risks hidden in prior claims.
Leading defense teams working with newcase.ai are already gaining a decisive edge. For example, in expert witness cross-exams, they instantly surface critical insights and contradictions across dozens of prior expert testimonies, ensuring they never miss a critical fact. In an industry where 96% of matters settle, and past data remains locked in PDFs and siloed systems, newcase.ai unlocks untapped insights that help attorneys move faster, defend smarter, and reduce cost.
Why Is This Problem Significant, & How Large Is Its Impact?
Litigation defense is both time-intensive and cost-heavy. Attorneys often spend hundreds of hours sifting through unindexed records, while still missing key facts. At scale, this leads to billions in wasted legal spend, weaker strategies, and inconsistent outcomes.
The problem is enormous: insurers spend over $100 billion annually on litigation and defense, with lawyers losing up to 60% of their time to manual research. As plaintiff-side firms rapidly adopt AI-driven tools, the imbalance is growing, and the need for intelligent, scalable defense technology is urgent.
newcase.ai levels the playing field by unlocking proprietary defense-side data and automating deep document analysis, giving defense teams an edge in high-volume, high-stakes litigation.
Over the past two years, over $600M has been invested in AI tools that help plaintiff firms generate larger demands, widening the gap for defense. LLMs now make it possible to mine the 96%+ of proprietary past case data, turning hidden insights into decisive advantages in high-volume, high-stakes defense litigation.
Meet the Team Behind newcase.ai
Built on years of personal and professional partnership, newcase.ai’s founders combine legal and AI expertise with proven execution:
- Nader Karayanni (CEO) is a repeat founder, former Microsoft engineer, and published AI researcher, shaped by lifelong exposure to insurance litigation through his father’s 35-year law firm.
- Mustafa Awad (COO) is a dual-qualified lawyer and accountant with expertise in litigation workflows and operations.
Together, they’re building what legacy players missed: a defense-first AI platform designed for the unique challenges of insurance litigation.


Co-Founder & CEO
“Insurance litigation attorneys face one of the most data-heavy and inefficient processes in modern law. Because 96% of matters settle, crucial past case data remains private and unindexed.
We saw firsthand how litigation teams spend hundreds of hours per claim while barely scratching the surface of the insights hidden within their proprietary past case data.
Today, we’re excited to announce our $1.15M pre-seed round to build the first litigation intelligence platform designed specifically for defense. The combination of untapped potential and outdated manual processes makes this one of the rare and exciting opportunities to drive real value through vertical-specific innovation.”
Why We’re Excited to Invest
newcase.ai is tackling one of the biggest, most expensive pain points in insurance defense, an area where inefficiency and data overload cost insurers billions every year.
The product sits at the intersection of AI, legaltech, and insurtech, with a clear ecosystem fit and first-mover advantage on the defense side, where technology adoption has lagged. By transforming unstructured litigation data into actionable insights, newcase.ai doesn’t just improve attorney productivity, it creates defensible IP, sticky integrations with case management systems, and the potential to become a critical infrastructure layer for insurers, TPAs, and law firms.
The market is massive, the problem is urgent, and the company is positioned to build a category-defining platform in a space that has been overlooked for too long. Early pilots have shown impressive results: reviews that once took weeks can now be completed in hours with higher accuracy. In head-to-head comparisons with other AI legal tools, customers have found newcase.ai to be the most effective solution for insurance defense, with one insurer already exploring a rollout across its national legal network.
Plug and Play is one of the most active VCs in Silicon Valley. Our goal is to fund the teams building the defensible businesses of the future. Join our ecosystem today.



